Click here for Pulp & Paper Radio International
The Paperitalo Library
Free Downloads
My Profile
Temple-Inland Rejects IP's Unsolicited Tender Offer

Austin, Texas, USA, 18 July 2011 -- (BUSINESS WIRE) -- Temple-Inland Inc. (NYSE: TIN) today announced that its board of directors, after careful consideration with its independent financial and legal advisors, voted unanimously to reject the unsolicited tender offer from International Paper Company (NYSE: IP) to acquire all outstanding common shares of Temple-Inland at a price of USD 30.60 per share in cash. The board unanimously determined that the offer grossly undervalues Temple-Inland and is not in the best interests of Temple-Inland's stockholders. The board unanimously recommends that Temple-Inland stockholders not tender their shares into IP's offer.

The basis for the board's recommendation with respect to IP's tender offer is set forth in Temple-Inland's schedule 14D-9, filed today with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), a copy of which is available at www.sec.gov and on Temple-Inland's Web site at www.templeinland.com.

"Since we launched the 'new' Temple-Inland in January 2008, we have delivered superior results to our stockholders compared with our corrugated packaging peers, building products peers, and the S&P 500. The Temple-Inland board is unanimous in its belief that the offer grossly undervalues Temple-Inland and its prospects, including its position as the return on asset leader in the corrugated packaging industry, expected benefits from box plant transformation, its low-cost building products operation, and its strategic place within the industry as the third largest producer of corrugated packaging in North America," said Doyle R. Simons, chairman and chief executive officer of Temple-Inland.

As fully outlined in Temple-Inland's schedule 14D-9, Temple-Inland's board recommends that Temple-Inland stockholders not tender their shares into IP's offer for the following reasons:

  • International Paper's unsolicited offer grossly undervalues Temple-Inland and its future prospects:
    • The board believes Temple-Inland's accelerating growth of earnings and return on investment will result in superior value to Temple-Inland's stockholders as compared to the price being offered by IP.
    • IP overstates Temple-Inland's net debt. The company's net debt at the end of first quarter 2011 was USD 737 million, not USD 828 million as IP calculated for purposes of pricing its offer.
    • IP wrongly characterizes Temple-Inland's timber financing transaction as a liability rather than an asset. IP appears to have considered only one aspect of the transaction, the present value of the settlement of the tax on the deferred gain, and ignored the remaining positive components (including alternative minimum tax credits) of the transaction, which together result in a net benefit.
    • IP's offer fails to appropriately compensate Temple-Inland stockholders for the very significant synergies that IP would realize and the extraordinary level of earnings accretion that would result if an IP/Temple-Inland transaction were to occur.
    • IP seeks to compare its offer price to valuation metrics from so-called "precedent" transactions that involved underperforming assets of other companies that are not comparable to Temple-Inland and its industry-leading returns, high-quality assets and low-cost structure.
    • IP's offer does not appropriately reflect the fundamental changes and improved focus in the corrugated packaging industry. These fundamental changes and improved industry focus are expected to be beneficial to Temple-Inland, which, as a result of its strong position in the corrugated packaging industry and its low-cost operations, is well positioned to continue to achieve improving results.
    • Temple-Inland is the largest remaining independent, publicly-held industry participant whose acquisition would fundamentally transform the industry, and IP's offer does not appropriately compensate Temple-Inland's stockholders for that strategic value.
  • The timing of International Paper's unsolicited proposal is extremely opportunistic and disadvantageous to Temple-Inland stockholders:
    • Housing markets are at historically low levels, temporarily depressing the value of our building products operations. IP is attempting to take advantage of our stockholders by moving to grab Temple-Inland at a bargain price at a time when there is little or no market value being ascribed to building products.
    • As IP itself has consistently highlighted to the investment community, corrugated packaging demand remains below prerecession levels, but is expected to recover in the near future as the economy continues to improve. IP is attempting by its offer to acquire Temple-Inland before corrugated packaging demand returns to prerecession levels and pricing further improves.
    • Temple-Inland estimates that USD 90 million of the annual cost savings from its Box Plant Transformation II project are still to be realized - Temple-Inland's stockholders, not IP's, deserve to receive the benefit of the significant capital Temple-Inland has invested in this project.
    • IP initially publicized its proposal to acquire Temple-Inland during a period of market weakness in order to claim an inflated "premium."
  • The potential acquisition is subject to regulatory and other uncertainty:
    • IP is proposing a combination of the largest and third largest producers of corrugated packaging in North America.
    • Given the regulatory uncertainty and the significant conditionality of IP's offer, there is considerable uncertainty regarding the offer and the timing of Temple-Inland stockholders receiving the "certain" value that IP claims to be offering.

As noted above, the company's schedule 14D-9 is available on the SEC's Web site, www.sec.gov. In addition, the schedule 14D-9 and other materials related to IP's unsolicited proposal are available in the "Investor Relations" section of the company's Web site at www.templeinland.com. The company urges stockholders to read the schedule 14D-9 carefully and in its entirety.

Goldman, Sachs & Co. is acting as financial advisor to Temple-Inland, and Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz is acting as Temple-Inland's legal counsel.

Temple-Inland Inc. is a manufacturing company focused on corrugated packaging and building products. The fully integrated corrugated packaging operation consists of seven mills and 58 converting facilities. The building products operation manufactures a diverse line of building products for new home construction, commercial, and repair and remodeling markets. Temple-Inland's Internet address www.templeinland.com.


Related Articles:

Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: